← All problems

Descriptive Scientific experiment

Ordinary people, an order to carry out

On the axis: Vision of humanity · the ordinary person under authority

That ordinary people inflict the worst on a mere order: is it a latent cruelty waking up, or proof that circumstances, not nature, decide our acts?

This problem is brought out by the thought experiment The Milgram experiment:

In a famous psychology experiment, a scientist asks ordinary volunteers to inflict ever-stronger electric shocks on a stranger each time he answers wrong, in the name of a study on learning. The stranger, an actor, cries out, pleads, then falls silent. Despite their visible distress, most volunteers obey up to the level marked "danger: severe shock", simply because a lab coat keeps repeating: "The experiment requires that you continue."

Stanley Milgram (1963)

What does this obedience teach us about human beings?

Possible answers

Your choice above is recorded in your profile. See my profile →

Anchors: Arendt · Hobbes