← All problems

PrescriptivePolitical & legal

Remembering or turning the page

On the axis: Relation to the past · a people's past

Should a society keep alive the memory of its wrongs and its defeats, or must it, to live together, consent to a measure of forgetting?

Philosophers' positions

Nietzsche

Major
−0.9
Justification

works as a test: if a demon told you that you will relive this very life, identically, infinitely, would you curse him, or would it be your greatest joy? To say yes to every instant is : not 's resignation, but the highest affirmation, to love the necessary so much that one wills its eternal return.

My formula for greatness in a human being is amor fati: that one wants nothing to be different, not forward, not backward, not in all eternity.Ecce Homo, "Why I Am So Clever", §10

Ecce Homo, "Why I Am So Clever", §10 · The Gay Science, §276 and §341

inferable
70
30
0
Justification

and command us to love the moment enough to will its eternal repetition: the weight falls on the fullness of the affirmed present. A share of project remains, since the is a task to accomplish, but Nietzsche devalues the excess of historical memory that paralyzes action.

The Gay Science, §341 · On the Use and Abuse of History for Life, §1

Positions over time

The philosophers positioned on the axis “Relation to the past”, over time. Hover a dot to read its name.

↑ Revolt↓ Amor fatiTheir position on this axis has not been mapped in Philoscopia yet: it does not mean they took none.Not yet placed on this axis200 BCE05001000150016001700180019002000Zhuangzi (369 BCE – 286 BCE)ZhuangziEpicurus (341 BCE – 270 BCE)EpicurusSeneca (4 BCE – 65)SenecaEpictetus (50 – 135)EpictetusMarcus Aurelius (121 – 180)Marcus AureliusSpinoza (1632 – 1677)SpinozaCamus (1913 – 1960)CamusNietzsche (1844 – 1900)NietzschePaul Ricœur (1913 – 2005) · Their position on this axis has not been mapped in Philoscopia yet: it does not mean they took none.Paul Ricœur

This problem's anchors

Anchors: Renan · Nietzsche · Ricœur

leads to: Forgiveness (The forgiveness of peoples) · Temporal orientation (The weight of heritage)