← See the axis · The highest good
ObjectionAttacks the positionThe cult of self-overcoming
To make self-overcoming the supreme value is to turn yourself into your own torturer.
Objects to
Alain Ehrenberg · The Cult of Performance; The Weariness of the Self · 1998
- The path of self-overcoming makes effort on oneself the seat of the good: to conquer oneself, to be disciplined, to go further than yesterday would be worth more than to enjoy or to succeed.
- But to make self-overcoming the supreme value is to give oneself a measure with no end: there is always someone stronger, faster, a record to break, a yesterday-self to humble. The installs at the heart of oneself a judge that never says "that is enough".
- The athlete offers its image: whoever is worth only as much as they surpass themselves wears out proving it, and lives each limit not as a fact, but as a fault. Alain Ehrenberg named this underside "the weariness of the self": depression as the shadow cast by the injunction to keep performing.
- What was meant to forge character therefore gnaws at it: discipline turns into inner tyranny, demandingness into violence against oneself.
Therefore So to make self-overcoming the highest good is not to rise, it is to condemn oneself: a value with no measure becomes a master with no mercy.
Deepenings
Where the injunction to surpass oneself comes from
- Ehrenberg locates the origin of this ill in a shift: yesterday, the individual measured themselves against what was permitted or forbidden; today, against what is possible, against what they could achieve.
- But nothing outside comes any longer to say "you have reached your place": freed from prohibitions, the self becomes its own endless task, alone responsible for its success as for its failure, and exhaustion replaces the guilt of former times.
Possible resolutions of the objection