All themes

Democracy

This theme runs through several big questions. Here are the ones where it plays out.

The questions that illuminate it

Relation to othersIdeal and reality

Should politics aim at the ideal city, or work with human beings as they are?

Aiming at the ideal city can inspire and uplift, but also justify every sacrifice in the name of a future that never comes; taking people as they are averts catastrophe, but can resign itself to injustice in the name of "realism." To take a position is to say whether politics should pursue the best or ward off the worst.

UtopianismPoliticalrealismPlatoMarxMachiavelliYOU

Explore this axis and its positions in detail
Relation to othersPolitical liberty

What is it to be politically free?

To be free, is it to be unhindered, to govern oneself, or to depend on no one's good will? Depending on the answer, what a society must guarantee, and what it must protect us from, changes entirely.

Negative libertyPositive libertyRepublican non-dominationCapability freedomYOU
Callicles
85
15
Mill
80
10
10
Liberalism
65
5
5
25
Hegel
5
85
10
Rousseau
5
80
15
Machiavelli
10
25
65
+ 3 more figures

Explore this axis and its positions in detail
Relation to othersRelation to authority

Is a political authority that commands and coerces necessary, or should we free ourselves from it?

It all turns on what we expect of human beings left to themselves: able to order their own affairs, or bound for disorder without a power to settle disputes. To take a position is to set how far the duty to obey extends, and where the right to refuse begins.

AuthorityAnarchismConstitutionalismConfuciusThe EnlightenmentDiogenes of SinopeYOU

Explore this axis and its positions in detail
Relation to othersWho should decide

Do political decisions belong to everyone, or first to the most competent?

Giving everyone an equal voice can hand grave choices to ignorance or passion; reserving power for the most knowledgeable can hide the interests of the powerful behind "expertise" and strip people of a say over their own lives. To take a position is to say where the legitimacy to decide comes from: the equality of all, or the competence of a few.

RadicaldemocracyEpistocracyRousseauMachiavelliPlatonismYOU

Explore this axis and its positions in detail