← All practices

ExerciseAttested · Thomas Aquinas

The disputed question: argue against yourself first

Before you answer, argue the opposing case better than its advocate would.

In the Summa Theologiae, never advances a thesis without first marshalling the strongest objections against it, then giving his reasoned position, then answering each objection one by one. This scholastic method of the quaestio turns disagreement into an instrument: a truth that holds withstands the best opposing reasons. Today, before settling a contested question, it keeps you from fighting a caricature and gives your position a tested foundation.

Put this practice to work

The step-by-step routine, with its variants for your position, comes with a Premium account: every practice, for life.

Discover the Premium account

Already have a Premium account? Sign in to get it back.

Enacts

Source: Thomas Aquinas