← All practices

RuleAttested · Peirce

By what method am I holding this belief?

Ask not whether your belief is true, but by which method you hold it.

In "The Fixation of Belief", distinguishes four ways of settling doubt: tenacity (I cling to what I already believe), authority (I believe it because I was told to), the a priori method (I believe it because it seems agreeable to reason, to my taste), and the method of science (I believe it because it answers to public facts that could correct it). This rule does not hand you instant certainty: it makes you notice how you actually hold a belief, and invites you to move it toward the last method, the only one that answers to communal checking and stays open to revision.

Put this practice to work

The step-by-step routine, with its variants for your position, comes with a Premium account: every practice, for life.

Discover the Premium account

Already have a Premium account? Sign in to get it back.

Enacts

Source: Peirce