Relation to oneself· Identity and freedom
Narrativism
Axis: Nature of the self — What makes me remain myself through time?
The self is built like a story: we become who we are by telling and reinterpreting our own history. Identity is neither given nor illusory; it is the ever-resumed work of a life woven into a plot.
Movements 1
Show inferred positions (1)
Existentialisminferable
The self is no fixed substance hidden behind existence: it is a task, something made through one's choices, whose unity is only the narrative unity of the project that takes it up. For the self is a relation that relates to itself and must be won; for the for-itself has no given essence. Hence a conception of the self as constructed, close to narrativism.
Kierkegaard, The Sickness unto Death · Being and Nothingness
Philosophers 3
Show inferred positions (3)
Sartreinferable
All consciousness is consciousness of something: it is therefore no substance, no thing-self lodged within it, but a presence to itself separated from itself by a nothingness. It is this gap, not an ego (against and ), that makes the for-itself never what it is and is what it is not: the condition of its freedom and its temporality.
Being and Nothingness, Part 1, ch. 1 (the for-itself is not what it is) · Being and Nothingness, Part 2 (the transcendent ego; cf. The Transcendence of the Ego)
Beauvoirinferable
The self is neither a substance nor a fixed essence: it is what it makes of itself through its choices and its history. In The Second Sex as in her Memoirs, the subject appears as a becoming constituted by a life-narrative, a series of projects taken up and reinterpreted, with no core given once and for all, hence a clear narrativist dominance.
The Second Sex (1949), becoming-woman · Memoirs of a Dutiful Daughter (1958)
Michel de Montaigneinferable
Montaigne finds in himself no fixed substance. The self is "the sway", a flux of moods, opinions and states contradictory from one instant to the next, closer to a shifting bundle than to a stable soul. What nonetheless holds it together is no essence but, it seems, the continued writing of the , which recaptures this passing in a self-portrait never closed: hence a narrative strand that tempers the sheer patchwork of the parts. For him the self is not given, it is composed in the very telling.
Essays, III, 2, "Of Repentance" and II, 1, "Of the Inconsistency of Our Actions"
- Descriptive Thought experimentThe teletransporter
If you are scanned here, your body destroyed, and an exact copy with all your memories rebuilt on Mars, is it you who arrives, or did you die, replaced by a double who believes he is you?
a person - DescriptiveIs the self made alone?
Does one become oneself through introspection alone, as a self-sufficient subject, or through the gaze and recognition of others, without whom the "I" would not take shape?
the self and others - DescriptiveA given self or a self to make?
Do I have a nature that precedes me and that I have to discover, or do I become what I choose to be, with no model fixed in advance?
the self