← Back to the axis

Relation to oneself· Adversity

The principle of hope

Axis: HopeIs hope a force that sustains life and action, or an illusion we ought to let go of?

To hope is not to indulge in illusions: it is a condition of action and progress. Hope directs our efforts toward what is not yet, sustains moral commitment, and opens the future as a field of possibility.

Who holds this position

Philosophers 2

Thomas Aquinasexplicit

Hope is for Thomas one of the three theological virtues: stretched toward the arduous but possible future good that is beatitude, it relies on the help of divine grace. Far from a lucidity without hope, Christian existence is oriented by the confident expectation of an end that surpasses the powers of nature, which places Thomas at the extreme of the pole of hope.

Summa Theologiae, IIa-IIae, q. 17-22

Kantexplicit

"What may I hope?" is one of the three cardinal questions of philosophy. The postulates of practical reason, freedom, immortality of the soul and God, ground a rational hope that the highest good, the accord of virtue and happiness, is possible: an avowed principle of hope.

Critique of Pure Reason, Canon of Pure Reason · Critique of Practical Reason, Dialectic

Foundations and implications
↑ What grounds itThe principle of hope — Hope!The principle ofhopeHope
Prescriptive
Metaphysical optimism — Tonality of reality=MetaphysicaloptimismTonality of reality
Descriptive
Evil has its reasons — The problem of evil=Evil has its reasonsThe problem of evil
Descriptive
Free will — Freedom of the will=Free willFreedom of the will
Descriptive
Theism — Existence of God=TheismExistence of God
Descriptive
Existentialism — Essence and existence=ExistentialismEssence and existence
Descriptive
Substance dualism — The enigma of consciousness=Substance dualismThe enigma of consciousness
Descriptive
Atheism — Existence of God=AtheismExistence of God
Descriptive
Nominalism — Universals=NominalismUniversals
Descriptive
Dualism — Nature of reality=DualismNature of reality
Descriptive
Materialism — Nature of reality=MaterialismNature of reality
Descriptive
Empiricism — Source of knowledge=EmpiricismSource of knowledge
Descriptive
A leaf — an application that grounds nothing further here.

What grounds it

Tonality of reality

If reality is ordered toward the good and history progresses, hope is not an illusion but a correct reading of the world. Metaphysical optimism grounds the principle of hope: to expect the best is to attune oneself to the very meaning of the real. Kant indeed ranks hope among reason's cardinal questions, "what may I hope for?".

What it implies

A leaf — an application that grounds nothing further here.