← See the axis · The point of philosophy
ObjectionAttacks the positionTo heal oneself, or to seek the truth?
Making philosophy a medicine for the soul risks reducing it to a consolation, one that prefers inner peace to truth.
Objects to
Socrates · Apology of Socrates
- Philosophy-as-exercise is judged by its effect on the one who practices it: it is worth something if it soothes, heals, helps one live better.
- But what consoles is not necessarily what is true: a comforting illusion 'heals' better than a bitter truth. To measure philosophy by its benefit is to risk preferring what soothes to what is.
- And turning toward one's own salvation may turn one away from the world: while one works on one's serenity, injustice remains. The art of living risks being merely a retreat, a care of self that abandons truth and others.
Therefore So philosophy cannot be reduced to a therapy: the search for truth may disquiet rather than soothe, and to think is not first of all to heal oneself.
Possible resolutions of the objection
Challenges